There
Is No Way To Stop Europe's First Domino From Falling
By Charles
Hugh Smith
The
dominoes of debt are toppling in Europe, and there is no way to stop the forces
of financial gravity.
After
19 months of denial, propaganda and phony fixes, the political and finance
leaders of the European Union are claiming a "comprehensive solution"
will be presented by Wednesday, October 26 — or maybe by the G20 meeting on November 3, or maybe
on Christmas, when Santa Claus delivers the gift global markets are demanding:
a "solution" that actually pencils out and that forces monumental
writeoffs of debt and thus equally monumental losses on European banks and
bondholders.
There have been any number of
insightful descriptions of what's going on beneath the artifice, spin and lies,
for example:
There Is No Bailout Spoon: The Math
Behind The €2 Trillion EFSF Reveals A "Pea Shooter" Not A
"Bazooka" (Zero Hedge)
Citi Expects A 76% Haircut On Greek
Debt (Zero Hedge)
I
have summarized the fundamentals in this one graphic: the European dominoes of
debt. Simply put, there is no
way the EU authorities can stop the first domino — Greek default or equivalent
writedown of its impossible debt load — from toppling the over-leveraged banks
which will be rendered insolvent when forced to recognize their losses.
That leaves each nation with
the politically unsavory option of bailing out its premier banks with taxpayer
money, and squeezing the money out of its citizenry via higher taxes and
austerity. That assumption of bank debt will in turn trigger downgrades of heavily
indebted sovereign nations such as France — moves that will raise rates and
make the bailout even more costly to taxpayers, who will also be suffering from
reductions of income due to global recession.
Once the banks and bondholders
accept a 50%–75% writedown in Greek debt, then the other debtor nations will be
justified in demanding the same writedown in their crushing debts. This dynamic
leads to estimates that 3 trillion euros will be needed to bail all the players
out. Alternatively, total losses will equal 3 trillion euros, wiping out banks
and bondholders of sovereign debt.
The
German economy is simply not big enough to fund a 3 trillion-euro bailout. Germany has 81 million
people and its GDP is $3.3 trillion; the EU GDP is roughly $16
trillion. Compare those with the U.S., with 315 million people and a GDP of
around $14.6 trillion.
As an act of
self-preservation, Germany will be forced to either exit the euro outright or
cloak its withdrawal with a "euro 1 and euro 2" scheme, a scenario I
first laid out in March 2010: Why the Euro Might Devolve into Euro1
and Euro2 (March
2, 2010). Other recent entries on the end-state of the European debt crisis:
The Eurozone's Three Fatal Flaws (September 21, 2011)
The Dynamics of Doom: Why the Eurozone Fix Will Fail (July 25, 2011)
Why The European Union Is Doomed (March 28, 2011)
The Dynamics of Doom: Why the Eurozone Fix Will Fail (July 25, 2011)
Why The European Union Is Doomed (March 28, 2011)
In any event, the last domino
— the artifice of a single currency — will fall one way or another.
It's
important to understand that the supposedly "prudent" economies of
France, Germany, South Korea and Canada are just as heavily indebted as the
U.S. or "drowning in debt" nations such as Italy. In the long view, is
Germany's load of 284% of GDP really that different from Italy's 313%? Yes, the
mix of debt is different, but the point is that all of Europe, and indeed the
developed world, is overloaded with debt: state, bank and private.
It
has recently come to light that in the worst-case scenario (i.e. reality),
"solving" Greece's debt crisis would absorb the entire EFSF Rescue
Fund's 400 billion euros. By all accounts, every estimate of Greek tax revenue is overstated,
and every estimate of its expenses understated; Greek GDP is collapsing. In all
probability, the reality is worse than anyone is willing to confess, which
means this chart is already outdated and hopelessly rosy:
Way back in August, the euro
was reckoned to be 20% above fair value of 1.15 to the U.S. dollar. Once the
dominoes start toppling in earnest, what will the euro's fair value be? Parity,
or perhaps even lower? Why hold euros when the end-game is already visible?
No comments:
Post a Comment