The flower in the seed
“We paid our Social Security and
Medicare taxes; we earned our benefits.” It is that belief among senior
citizens that President Obama was pandering to when, in his second inaugural
address, he claimed that those programs “strengthen us. They do not make us a
nation of takers.”
If Social Security and Medicare both
involved people voluntarily financing their own benefits, an argument could be
made for seniors’ “earned benefits” view. But they have not. They have
redistributed tens of trillions of dollars of wealth to themselves from those
younger.
Social Security and Medicare have
transferred those trillions because they have been partial Ponzi schemes.
After Social Security’s creation, those
in or near retirement got benefits far exceeding their costs (Ida Mae Fuller,
the first Social Security recipient, got 462 times what she and her employer
together paid in “contributions”). Those benefits in excess of their taxes paid
inherently forced future Americans to pick up the tab for the difference. And
the program’s almost unthinkable unfunded liabilities are no less a burden on
later generations because earlier generations financed some of their own benefits, or because the
government has consistently lied that they have paid their own way.
Since its creation, Social Security has
been expanded multiple times. Each expansion meant those already retired paid
no added taxes, and those near retirement paid more for only a few years. But
both groups received increased benefits throughout retirement, increasing the
unfunded benefits whose burdens had to be borne by later generations. Thus,
each such expansion started another Ponzi cycle benefiting older Americans at
others’ expense.
Social Security benefits have been
dramatically increased. They doubled between 1950 and 1952. They were raised 15
percent in 1970, 10 percent in 1971, and 20 percent in 1972, in a heated
competition to buy the elderly vote. Benefits were tied to a measure that
effectively double-counted inflation and even now, benefits are over-indexed to
inflation, raising real benefit levels over time.
Disability and dependents’ benefits were
added by 1960. Medicare was added in 1966, and benefits have been expanded
(e.g., Medicare Part B, only one-quarter funded by recipients, and Part D’s
prescription drug benefit, only one-eighth funded by recipients).
The massive expansion of Social Security
is evident from the growing tax burden since its $60 per year initial maximum
(for employees and employers combined). Tax rates have risen and been applied
to more earnings, with Social Security now taking a combined 12.4 percent of
earnings up to $113,700 (and Medicare’s 2.9 percent combined rate applies to
all earnings, plus a 0.9 percent surtax beyond $200,000 of earnings).