Europe remains a truly ambitious work in progress
By Robert Kaplan
The idea of
Europe, in the minds of Westerners today, is an intellectual concept—liberal
humanism with a geographical basis—that emerged through centuries of material
and intellectual advancement, as well as a reaction to devastating military
conflicts in previous historical ages. The last such conflict was World War II,
which spawned a resolve to merge elements of sovereignty among democratic
states in order to set in motion a pacifying trend.
Alas,
this grand narrative now is under assault by underlying forces of history and
geography. The economic divisions seen today in the European Union, manifest in
the Continent’s debt crisis and pressures on the euro, have their roots, at
least partially, in contradictions that stretch far back into Europe’s past and
its existential struggle to grapple with the realities of its immutable
geographical structure. It is this legacy—somewhat deterministic and rarely
acknowledged—that Europe still must overcome and that therefore requires a
detailed description.
In
the years immediately before and after the collapse of the Berlin Wall,
intellectuals celebrated the ideal of Central Europe—Mitteleuropa—as a beacon
of relative multiethnic tolerance and liberalism within the Hapsburg Empire to
which the contiguous Balkans could and should aspire. But while the Continent’s
spiritual heart lies in Mitteleuropa, the political heart now lies slightly to
the northwest, in what we might call Charlemagne’s Europe. Charlemagne’s Europe
starts with the Benelux states, then meanders south along the Franco-German
frontier to the approaches of the Alps. To wit, there is the European Commission
and its civil service in Brussels, the European Court in the Hague, the treaty
town of Maastricht, the European Parliament in Strasbourg and so on. All these
places lie athwart a line running southward from the North Sea “that formed the
centerpiece and primary communications route of the Carolingian monarchy,”
observes the late scholar of modern Europe Tony Judt.1 The fact that this budding European
superstate of our own era is concentrated in Europe’s medieval core, with
Charlemagne’s capital city of Aachen (Aix-la-Chapelle) still at its very
center, is no accident. For nowhere on the Continent is Europe’s sea and land
interface quite as rich and profound as along this spinal column of Old World
civilization.