By Joel Kotkin
In the crushing wave that flattened much of the
Democratic Party last month, two left-leaning states survived not only intact
but in some ways bluer than before. New York and California, long-time rivals
for supremacy, may both have seen better days; but for Democrats, at least, the
prospects there seem better than ever.
That
these two states became such outliers from the rest of the United States
reflects both changing economics and demographics. Over the past decade, New
York and California underperformed in terms of job creation across a broad
array of industries. Although still great repositories of wealth, their
dominant metropolitan areas increasingly bifurcated between the affluent and
poor. The middle class continues to ebb away for more opportune climes.
Each
state has also developed a large and politically effective public sector. In
both states, no candidate opposed to its demands won statewide office in 2010.
At the same time, the traditional, broad-based business interest has become
increasingly ineffective; instead, some powerful groups such as big developers,
Wall Street, Silicon Valley, and Hollywood, became part of the “progressive”
coalition, willing and able to cut their own deals with the ruling Democratic
elite.