Waiting for Japan's economy to make a strong
recovery has been an ongoing game since 1990. Shall we play that game one more
time?
There have been many false dawns in Japan over
the past 20 years. Struggling with a combination of crushing debt and deadly
demographics, Japan’s economy has stubbornly refused to make progress, despite
numerous government efforts that range from currency devaluation to endless
public works projects.
None of this was enough, however, to prevent
further declines in the country’s
fertility rate, for
example, which only exacerbated deflationary pressures on the economy. Nor were
the collective set of policy measures enough to boot capital flows away from
the bond market, as Japan’s savers simply kept on saving.
For the past twenty years, value investors have
probed the individual names in the Nikkei for cash rich insurance companies,
debt-free manufacturing companies, and for rock-bottom low P/E names, all in
the hopes of riding a broader recovery higher. Alas, no sustainable recovery in
Japan’s economy or stock market has ever unfolded.
One can only smile at the reaction that more
senior, experienced Japan recoverists must now be feeling as they watch a new
generation succumb to the excitement of the latest resurrection of Japan’s
economy. That the Nikkei is up by 25% in just 90 days has triggered all sorts
of congratulatory commentary, even from Nobel Prize winners like Paul Krugman,
who also is swept up in the latest
round of recovery fever:
Krugman explains that one of the problems with modern central banking is that people believe they're too credible in their desire to stamp out inflation when it starts to pick up. So in other words, the Central Bank may say it will let growth and inflation run hot for awhile (so that nominal GDP can catch up to trend) but nobody believes that they'll actually do that. What Japan may be in the process of doing -- by having the Bank of Japan take orders from the Ministry of Finance and the new Prime Minister -- is solve this problem, by having the bank commit to being irresponsible.
Thankfully, Japan’s latest attempt to recover by
aggressive devaluation is almost assured to provide resolution to its
generational quagmire. But the outcome will not look anything like recovery.
Instead, Japan has entered the terminal
phase of its long, reflationary road.
Culturally, the frustration and exhaustion at
the country’s lack of progress has unsurprisingly led to this important
juncture. The Japan recoverists are correct that the latest round of monetary
policy “is not like the others.” However, the results are likely to provide a
real-world test case of the limits of Keynesian policy at a time when the world
faces scarce resources.
This final chapter will be spectacular. So in a lurid sort of way, we should be thankful
that Japan has now crossed the threshold and is ready to proceed to its
denouement.
The Miracle of Post-War Japan & Resource
Arbitrage
Students of ecological economics should pay
close attention. Japan is about to add itself as a test case.
Ecological Economics is a thesis
of elegant simplicity. Simply
put, the economy is a subset of the environment – and not, as
neoliberal economists would have you believe, the other way around. Economies
can "grow" up to the limit of the natural resources which they can
extract, or acquire.
In a time of cheap resources, when the cost of
inputs is extremely low, the importance of these inputs tends to be ignored.
Thus, we can see the most obvious implication of environmental economics is
that extraordinary profits can be harvested when the price of resource inputs
is low and the purchasing power of consumers in the market place is high.














