The
Supreme Court was poised to deliver conservatives a major victory by
overturning a hated liberal policy with little basis in the Constitution. A
majority of the justices had been appointed by Republican presidents. Some of
them were so conservative that Senate Democrats had attempted to prevent their
confirmation.
Yet when the much
anticipated ruling was finally handed down, the liberal policy was upheld with
fairly minor caveats. A Republican-appointed justice unexpectedly voted with
the liberal bloc. Instead of a victory, conservatives feared they had endured a
permanent defeat on an important issue, and in an election year to boot.
While this certainly
describes the past day’s events, it was also true 20 years ago. When the Senate
narrowly confirmed Clarence Thomas, liberals feared he would be the deciding
vote against Roe v. Wade.
Well, Thomas did rule that Roe was wrongly decided at his
first opportunity. But in 1992’s Planned Parenthood v. Casey,
a 5-4 majority affirmed the core holding of the infamous abortion decision.


















.jpg)