The populists who scapegoat intellectuals and trash civil liberties are Jacobins, not conservatives
By PETER VIERECK
During the Jacobin Revolution of 1793, in those quaint
days when the lower classes still thought of themselves as the lower classes,
it was for upper-class sympathies and for notreading
“subversive leftist literature” that aristocrats got in trouble.
Note the reversal in America. Here the lower classes seem to be the
upper classes–they have automobiles, lace curtains, and votes. Here, in consequence,
it is for alleged lower-class sympathies–for “leftist” sympathies–that the
aristocrats are purged by the lower class.
In reality those lower-class sympathies are microscopic in most of that
social register (Lodge, Bohlen, Acheson, Stevenson, and Harvard presidents) which McCarthy is trying to
purge; even so leftist sympathies are the pretext given for the purge. Why is
it necessary to allege those lower-class sympathies as pretext? Why the pretext
in the first place? Because in America the suddenly enthroned lower classes
cannot prove to themselves psychologically that they are now upper-class unless
they can indict for pro-proletariat subversion those whom they know in their
hearts to be America’s real intellectual and social aristocracy.