Bad debts were shifted from the private to the public sector, but they did not disappear
by Philipp Bagus
Still unnoticed by a large part of the
population is that we have been living through a period of relative
impoverishment. Money has been squandered in welfare
spending, bailing out banks or even — as in Europe — of fellow governments. But
many people still do not feel the pain.
However, malinvestments have destroyed an
immense amount of real wealth. Government
spending for welfare programs and military ventures has caused increasing
public debts and deficits in the Western world. These
debts will never be paid back in real terms.
The welfare-warfare state is the biggest
malinvestment today. It does not satisfy the preferences of
freely interacting individuals and would be liquidated immediately if it were
not continuously propped up by taxpayer money collected under the threat of
violence.
Another source of malinvestment has been
the business cycle triggered by the credit expansion of the semi-public
fractional reserve banking system. After the financial crisis of 2008, malinvestments were only partially
liquidated. The investors that had financed the malinvestments such as
overextended car producers and mortgage lenders were bailed out by governments;
be it directly through capital infusions or indirectly through subsidies and
public works. The bursting of the housing bubble caused losses for the banking
system, but the banking system did not assume these losses in full because it
was bailed out by governments worldwide.Consequently,
bad debts were shifted from the private to the public sector, but they did not
disappear. In
time, new bad debts were created through an increase in public welfare spending
such as unemployment benefits and a myriad of “stimulus” programs. Government
debt exploded.
In other words, the losses resulting from
the malinvestments of the past cycle have been shifted to an important degree
onto the balance sheets of governments and their central banks. Neither
the original investors, nor bank shareholders, nor bank creditors, nor holders
of public debt have assumed these losses. Shifting bad debts around cannot
recreate the lost wealth, however, and the debt remains.