Syria and Egypt are dying
By Spengler
They were dying
before the Syrian civil war broke out and before the Muslim Brotherhood took
power in Cairo. Syria has an insoluble civil war and Egypt has an insoluble
crisis because they are dying. They are dying because they chose not to do what
China did: move the better part of a billion people from rural backwardness to
a modern urban economy within a generation. Mexico would have died as well,
without the option to send its rural poor - fully one-fifth of its population -
to the United States.
It was obvious to anyone who troubled to examine the data that Egypt
could not maintain a bottomless pit in its balance of payments, created by a
50% dependency on imported food, not to mention an energy bill fed by subsidies
that consumed a quarter of the national budget. It was obvious to Israeli
analysts that the Syrian regime's belated attempt to modernize its agricultural
sector would create a crisis as hundreds of thousands of displaced farmers
gathered in slums on the outskirts of its cities. These facts were in evidence
early in 2011 when Hosni Mubarak fell
and the Syrian rebellion broke out. Paul Rivlin of Israel's
Moshe Dayan Center published a devastating profile of Syria's economic failure
in April 2011. [1]
Sometimes countries dig themselves into a hole from which they cannot
extricate themselves. Third World dictators typically keep their rural
population poor, isolated and illiterate, the better to maintain control. That
was the policy of Mexico's Institutional Revolutionary Party from the 1930s,
which warehoused the rural poor in Stalin-modeled collective farms called ejidos occupying
most of the national territory. That was also the intent of the Arab
nationalist dictatorships in Egypt and Syria. The policy worked until it
didn't. In Mexico, it stopped working during the debt crisis of the early
1980s, and Mexico's poor became America's problem. In Egypt and Syria, it
stopped working in 2011. There is nowhere for Egyptians and Syrians to
go.
It is cheap to assuage Western consciences by sending some surplus arms
to the Syrian Sunnis. No-one has proposed a way to find the more than US$20
billion a year that Egypt requires to stay afloat. In June 2011, then French
president Nicholas Sarkozy talked about a Group of Eight support program of
that order of magnitude. No Western (or Gulf State) government, though, is
willing to pour that sort of money down an Egyptian sinkhole.
Egypt remains a pre-modern society, with nearly 50% illiteracy, a 30%
rate of consanguineal marriage, a 90% rate of female genital mutilation, and an
un- or underemployment rate over 40%. Syria has neither enough oil nor water to
maintain the bazaar economy dominated by the Assad family.





.jpg)




.jpg)






.jpg)