There is one country that is speaking out against this madness: Germany
by Patrick Barron
What the media calls a “currency war,” whereby nations
engage in competitive currency devaluations in order to increase exports, is
really “currency suicide.” National governments persist in the fallacious
belief that weakening one’s own currency will improve domestically-produced
products’ competitiveness in world markets and lead to an export driven
recovery. As it intervenes to give more of its own currency in exchange for the
currency of foreign buyers, a country expects that its export industries will
benefit with increased sales, which will stimulate the rest of the economy. So
we often read that a country is trying to “export its way to prosperity.”
Mainstream economists everywhere believe that this
tactic also exports unemployment to its trading partners by showering them with
cheap goods and destroying domestic production and jobs. Therefore, they call
for their own countries to engage in reciprocal measures. Recently Martin Wolfe
in the Financial Times of London and Paul Krugman of the New York Times both accuse their countries’
trading partners of engaging in this “beggar-thy-neighbor” policy and recommend
that England and the US respectively enter this so-called “currency war” with
full monetary ammunition to further weaken the pound and the dollar.
I am struck by the similarity of this currency-war
argument in favor of monetary inflation to that of the need for reciprocal
trade agreements. This argument supposes that trade barriers against foreign
goods are a boon to a country’s domestic manufacturers at the expense of
foreign manufacturers. Therefore, reciprocal trade barrier reductions need to
be negotiated, otherwise the country that refuses to lower them will benefit.
It will increase exports to countries that do lower their trade barriers
without accepting an increase in imports that could threaten domestic industries
and jobs. This fallacious mercantilist theory never dies because there are
always industries and workers who seek special favors from government at the
expense of the rest of society. Economists call this “rent seeking.”
A Transfer of Wealth and a Subsidy
to Foreigners
As I explained in Value in Devaluation?, inflating
one’s currency simply transfers wealth within the country from non-export
related sectors to export related sectors and gives subsidies to foreign
purchasers.