America on Welfare
Living the good life on welfare. Even the Europeans recognize that they pay
a high price for creating an increasingly dependent society.
Denmark has been transfixed by the revelation of a 36-year-old single
mother who collects more in benefits than many Danes earn at work, and has done
so for two decades. Worried Karen Haekkerup, Minister of Social
Affairs and Integration, people “think of these benefits as their rights. The
rights have just expanded and expanded.”
But it’s really not that much different in the U.S., the nominal home of
the free. Nearly two decades ago welfare reform briefly captured political
attention and won bipartisan support. The effort was a great success. But most
welfare programs remained untouched and the gains have been steadily eroded.
Today nearly 48 million people, almost one out of every six Americans,
receive Food Stamps. Outlays on this program alone have quadrupled in just a
decade. Indeed, the government actively promotes the program, encouraging
people to sign up. Other welfare programs also are growing in reach and cost.
The Congressional Budget Office recently pointed to “increases in the number of
people participating in those programs and increases in spending per
participant.” The U.S. isn’t that far behind Europe.
Indeed, America, like Europe, has a veritable welfare industry. A
forthcoming report from the Carleson
Center for Public Policy, named after Reagan
administration welfare chief Robert Carleson, charges that “The federal
government has spawned a vast array of redundant, overlapping and poorly
targeted assistance programs.” Authors Susan Carleson and John Mashburn count
157 means-tested programs intended to alleviate poverty. There were more than
two score housing programs, more than a score of nutrition programs, almost as
many employment/training and health programs, and lesser numbers of cash
assistance, community development, and disability programs. More expansive
definitions count even more programs — 185 total, according to Peter Ferrara.
No surprise, the welfare industry is expensive. Social Security is the
single most costly program, but more goes collectively to welfare. Today
government at all levels spends around $1 trillion a year on means tested
anti-poverty programs. And that amount is just going up and up.
Total federal and state welfare spending rose from $431 billion in 2000 to
$927 billion in 2011. Both parties are responsible, but President Obama bears
particular responsibility. Last year, explained my Cato Institute colleague Michael
Tanner: “Welfare spending increased significantly under President George W.
Bush and has exploded under President Barack Obama. In fact, since President
Obama took office, federal welfare spending has increased by 41 percent, more
than $193 billion per year.”
And this is just the start. From 2009 to 2018, figured Heritage Foundation
scholars Robert Rector, Katherine Bradley, and Rachel Sheffield, at current
rates the federal government will spend $7.5 trillion and states will spend
$2.8 trillion on welfare, for a total of $10.3 trillion.