Call to Speed Up Creation of Banking Union
By Markus Dettmer
and Christian Reiermann
The EU's bailout
of Cyprus has elicited unusually frank and vehement criticism from the finance
experts grouped in the IMF's Executive Board. Their damning indictment at an
IMF meeting in May reflects global skepticism, especially in emerging
economies, about the euro zone's crisis management.
Paulo Nogueira
Batista, 58, is a fan of classical music, a connoisseur of German literature
and an advocate of straight talking. As executive director for his native
Brazil and 10 smaller countries, he is a member of the Executve Board, the highest-ranking
operational decision-making body of the International Monetary Fund (IMF).
His counterparts
from the United States and Europe have often witnessed the combative
personality of this economist with wavy, salt-and-pepper hair, who attended a
high school in Bonn for two years in his youth. Batista is one of the most
persistent critics of Western dominance in the IMF.
He often derides
the Washington-based organization, headed by French politician Christine
Lagarde, as a "North Atlantic monetary fund," because, as he argues,
Americans and Europeans are primarily interested in defending their interests
and preventing emerging economies like Brazil from exerting their rightful
influence in the fund. He resents the Europeans for increasingly availing
themselves of the fund's assets to combat their euro crisis, even though they
have enough money of their own. "The euro countries abuse their power
within the IMF," Batista is fond of saying.
In mid-May, the
Brazilian had yet another opportunity to sharply criticize the Europeans'
behavior. The bailout package for
Cyprus was up for a vote in the IMF Executive Board, a
package that includes €1 billion ($1.3 billion) in IMF funds. As it turned out,
there were others who shared the Brazilian's critical position.
As evidenced by
written position statements and the speaking notes of participants, the event
turned into a critical review of Europe's bailout policy. The IMF found itself
in the dock along with the European Commission and the European Central Bank
(ECB), the two other members of the so-called troika, as well as the countries
of the euro zone.